Thursday, May 2, 2013

Kentucky Derby Day 139
Kentucky Derby Analysis & Undercard Stakes Analysis


6-Churchill            5f    Turf Grade 3 Turf Sprint                    

1-Southern Dude (10/1) - Only 1-for-3 over the turf, but the last was a nice wire win and he's worked four times over the Louisville sod, including two bullet works.  Would not be a bad choice if rained to the main track....providing Leparoux can get him out of the gate from the rail.

2-Havelock (7/2) - He's won five of ten sprinting on the turf, and the last four wins showing on his resume are all photo finish wins!  His last, at the expense of my pick came as much through poor tactics (Leparoux, again) as Havelock being the best.  Obvious contender, but hard to believe he'll score back-to-back.

3-Regally Ready (4/1) - Has simply not been the same horse since winning the Grade 1 BC Turf Sprint in 2012, here.  But.....his last was off an eight month layoff and best of all - he is unbeaten over this course.  Hmmm, interesting.

4-Ghost Is Clear (9/2) - Another interesting runner....first, you can't ignore the hottest rider-trainer connection in America here:  Rosario / Maker.  And he's run well when sprinting over the turf (as well as over the main track).  Difficult to believe he'll win a Grade 3 when just last November you could have claimed him for $10K.  Rags to riches?

5-Cactus Son (30/1) - Before he's quickly dismissed as a longshot, consider this....last year in this same race he was closing fast to be third, beaten only 2 lengths at 25-1!  Uh oh!  Seems to have been in sharper form at the time though - you could do worse for price plays.

6-Chamberlain Bridge (4/1) - He's a SEVENTEEN time winner in turf sprints, a BC Champion over this course and has won 4-of-9 here.  But, he's nine now and has a single win over the last two years with three photo losses.  Wouldn't be a huge surprise, but seems a step slower these days.

7-Berlino de Tiger (15/1) - Third start in North America today will be part of the early pace picture before wilting under pressure.

8-Icon Ike (3/1) - Back-to-back career efforts, and wins.  He fits the track profile as a finisher, and has a good post to track the race flow.  Rosie the top rider in America has a live mount here.  Three works since that last race including a big bullet work over the Keeneland synthetic.  A major player in here.

7-Churchill            7f    Grade 1 Humana Distaff                     

1-Jamaican Smoke (5/1) - Speed on the rail, under Leparoux again, but since winning his entry-level allowance four back he's set the table in three straight stakes, only to surrender late.  COULD last today, but it's a big class rise here.

2-Rumor (5/2) - Beat the best west coast sprinting filly last time out in the Grade 3 Las Flores in a near-career best speed figure performance.  Has shown the ability to sit just off the pace or rally from farther back which means she won't be pace dependent, nor hounded on the front end.  Hall of Fame Mike Smith has been on board for her last four, of which two were stakes wins at 6 1/2 furlongs.  Win contender.

3-Same Cross (5/1) - Has been heavily favored in all four starts and you have to be impressed that not only did she not disappoint in debut maiden run, but was impressive in her next two as she cleared the nw1x and nw2x conditions easily.  Toss the turf effort last out.  Moves not only into stakes company, but all the way up to Grade 1 here.  Same connections as the turf sprint, the 30% team of Napravnik-Jones.  Dangerous.

4-Emma's Encore (8/1) - Live price play considering she'll be rolling late and should enjoy the long Churchill stretch to work out a winning effort, AND she's a Grade 1 winner.  "The Chief" - Hall of Fame trainer Allen Jerkens sends out this mare who was a disappointment at Gulfstream this winter.  Needs a form reversal, but with the right pace picture.....

5-There Is No Limit (15/1) - High level claiming winner who just cleared nw1x level - not today.

6-Aubby K (7/2) - She's only been out seven times and she's won three of them.  The four fillies/mares she was beaten by were:  On Fire Baby, Contested (twice) and Grace Hall - all multiple graded stakes winners!  She has the ability to run huge and she may have even more room for improvement.  Edgar Prado having a resurgent year.  Looks good here.

7-Burban (10/1) - Speed figures are double digits below what it will take to win; beaten nearly ten by Aubby K two races back.

8-Byrama (5/1) - She will take plenty of action because (a) she's lured Rosario to ride and (b) she just missed in the Grade 1 Madison at this level last out.  But to me she has NO SHOT.  Until her latest she was strictly a turf runner and her last two wins were in listed turf sprints.  The Madison is run over Keeneland's synthetic main which plays like turf, so no big surprise she ran well that day.  Makes her FIRST CAREER START on dirt today!

9-Holiday Soiree (12/1) - Will want to be part of the early pace, but the outside draw will discourage that.  Looks overmatched in here

8-Churchill            8f - Turf  Grade 2 Churchill Distaff Mile        

1-Drama Drama (30/1) - Two wins, one her maiden win and one at the nw1x level.  Looks very overmatched.

2-Channel Lady (12/1) - How often do you get 12/1 on a Todd Pletcher graded stakes winner?  She fits the pace scenario and has won at the distance.  Bejarano a strong finishing rider as well.  Upset chance.

3-Daisy Devine (3/1) - Speed to burn and she draws inside the other speed.  She was a monster in listed stakes over the winter and clearly best-of-the-rest in the Grade 1 Jenny Wiley last out after having a clear lead into the lane.  Not so sure she can run with the other pace player in here in spite of the inside draw.  Also, her goal all winter was the Jenny Wiley so I'm not so sure she's geared for a top effort here.

4-Frontside (30/1) - The other speed, and she appears quicker than Daisy, but she also is not in the same class as that gal.  I think she's a pace player to the far turn that has no chance to win, but has every chance to spoil the chances of any other filly on the front end.

5-Hungry Island (4/1) - A year ago she had a prep race at Keeneland at a mile, where she ran well, and then in her second start off the layoff she WON this very race.  This year she had a prep at Keeneland - and won - now moves to the Churchill Distaff second off the shelf!  Look out!  Shug McGaughey runners are having a great year and Javier Castellano is a top turf rider.  She will have a good pace to close into.  Looks dangerous to defend her title at a fair price.

6-Stephanie's Kitten (4/1) - She is a 2x winner here, including a Breeders' Cup win at this distance.  But I'm concerned that the last SEVEN Beyer figures earned by Hungry Island are ALL better than the lifetime best of Kitten.

7-Karlovy Vary (12/1) - Will be pressing all the pace players and get first jump into the lane, but don't think she measures up to the closers will battle for the top prize on the wire.

8-Marketing Mix (5/2) - She had a great season in 2012 and had the lead in deep stretch of the Grade 1 Breeders' Cup Filly & Mare Turf, only to be nailed late by multiple Grade 1 winner Zagora.  She has not run since then, but trainer Tom Proctor is a 26% winner with runners off such layoffs.  Gomez & Proctor are deadly when handling a Glen Hills Farm runner, like Marketing Mix.  Her main rival, Hungry Island, have met three times, with that rival besting her in this spot last year - when Marketing Mix was my selecction :( - but on that day she was in traffic and had to wait through the lane.  That proved to be the first of two losses where she probably should have won, but rider Julien Leparoux did not give her every chance to win.  He was replaced by Gomez who produced a dominant Grade 1 win and near miss in the BC.  Her seven for eleven in the exacta mark on the turf with earnings of $1.5 million stamp her as the class of the race and I think she kicks off her 2013 season in a big way here today.

9-Class Included (30/1) - Winless in two tries over the grass, and beaten by rank 30-1 outsider Frontside two back.

10-Stopshoppingmaria (10/1) - Speedy miss had a resurgent winter as she moved through her conditions and won the Gulfstream Lady's Turf Sprint Stakes.  While it's true she nearly wired the Grade 2 Breeders' Cup Juvenile Fillies Turf at this distance over this course, she will be compromised by other speed types and her outside draw.

 

9-Churchill            7f    Grade 2 Churchill Downs                    

1-Night Party (30/1) - Looks overmatched in this spot but should provide pace pressure.

2-Hiero (10/1)- Could be a very dangerous longshot in this spot.  First of all he's 2-for-2 over the Churchill main track and one of those was at this distance, the other was the Grade 3 Derby Trial.  Two back he scored at 7/5 when making his first start for Todd Pletcher.  Disappointed at odds-on in his last, but that makes today his third start off the shelf.  John Velazquez-Todd Pletcher at 10/1 with a graded stakes winner who's won over the track?  Uh oh.....

3-Laurie's Rocket (10/1) - Has won three of his last five, but is 0-for-3 at the distance and looks outclassed here.

4-Handsome Mike (12/1) - His last two wins, both graded stakes, were surprise attacks.  He unleashed tote board bombs at 19/1 in the Pennsylvania Derby last fall and then in his last he won the Grade 3 Commonwealth at 7/2.  Would be a surprise today in spite of his 2012 Derby connections.

5-Unbridled's Note (5/1) - Made his first start on the turf in the Grade 3 Eddie D, which led to him being the favorite in the BC Turf Sprint down the hill.  Second (to my longshot winner, whooo hooo!) and then was life-and-death to score in a listed stakes over the downhill course.  That came squeezed between two main track close finishes in graded sprints.  Looks to be a "I like to be close without winning" type in these big events.  Wouldn't be a big surprise, but doesn't appear to be "the one" today.

6-Pass the Dice (12/1) - Has won five of eight career starts, including a triple Beyer win over Hierro last out going a one-turn mile at Gulfstream in allowance company.  Steps up in class today with an upset chance.

7-Politicallycorrect (15/1) - On the "glass is half full" side he's 4/2-1-0 at today's distance and keeps Joel Rosario in the saddle.  On the "glass is half empty" side, he was beaten more than ten lengths by today's rival Unbridled's Note.

8-Trinniberg (8/5) - The defending Grade 1 Breeders' Cup Sprint Champion and Eclipse award winning sprinter from 2012 makes his first 2013 US start today.  And there-in lies the rub.  Horses making their first start after a trip to Dubai are often knocked out - strike one.  This guy disappointed me personally when failing to win the Grade 2 Carry Back over a four horse field at Calder and the $300K Gallant Bob when I was at Parx last fall.  Many do not believe his BC win was a true picture of his talent, but simply a once-in-a-lifetime run.  I would be on that page.  I think he disappoints here, but will win sprint stakes through the summer.

9-Delauney (2/1) - Today is "breakout day" for this sprinter!  He has won FIVE STRAIGHT and ALL of them have earned triple Beyers.  His last two speed figures of 110 and 111 give him a double Beyer advantage over the LIFETIME best figures of the rest of his rivals today.  The comments about his winter string of wins was he was running "....Breeders' Cup figures....." will be justified today, I believe.  He gets top riding Rosie Napravnik on board again and as if you need more ammunition to support him, how about this - he's a FIVE-time winner at today's unique seven furlong distance and he is unbeaten in three starts over the Churchill Downs track.  MUCH the best today and it's on to a course pointed to the 2013 Breeders' Cup!

 

10-Churchill           9f - Turf  Grade 1 Woodford Reserve Classic      

1-Middie (30/1) - Eligible to outrun his odds and grab a share with two wins locally and experience/wins at the distance.  But with only a single Grade 3 on his resume he'd be a surprise to be in the winner's circle today.

2-Slim Shadey (12/1) - Hall of Fame jockey Gary Stevens is enjoying his return to racing with many quality wins, and he piloted this guy to a Grade 2 win two back on the front end.  Look for Stevens to shoot to the front and try to back the pace down while lulling the field to sleep.  He has three Gr 2 wins on the front end, but those were all at 10 furlongs.  May have to run quicker here to lead them, and that probably puts him in the role of a target for the big two.

3-Optimizer (20/1) - Had a wonderful winter in New Orleans as he took down back-to-back Grade 3 events.  But his rivals in those spots would pale to today's top contenders.  Fringe player in spite of Joel Rosario on board.

4-Silver Max (8/1) - He was one of the most exciting three-year-olds of 2012 as his lightning quick speed propelled him to six straight wire-to-wire wins at distances from a mile to a mile and a quarter; and three of those were graded stakes.  Seems to be having issues since moving up to face older rivals and you have to be concerned when he didn't even make the lead last time out in the Grade 3 Appleton (where he was my personal pick to steal it!).

5-Swift Warrior (20/1) - Well, on the positive side he's won back-to-back Grade 3 races, one at today's nine furlong distance and he gets Javier Castellano on board.  AND he should be positioned right off the speed to be one of the first to challenge once heads are turned for home.  On the downside he just does not appear fast enough or classy enough to deal with the outside two monsters of the race.

6-Jeranimo (8/1) - Nothing but Grade 1's and Grade 2's on his pp's and he's won four of those showing on his resume.  One includes a defeat of eventual BC Turf champion Little Mike, but he'd have to produce a lifetime best to challenge for the top spot here today.

7-Bim Bam (50/1)- I think his connections STILL hold on to that 2nd at 30-1 in the Grade 1 Manhattan back in June 2011 and think they have a chanced.  Winless for three years.....would be the shocker of the weekend.

8-Wise Dan (6/5) - The defending 2012 Horse of the Year steps outside his comfort zone - a mile on the turf - in making his second start of the season.  He was impressive in winning his debut, not only when not fully cranked for the race and defeating the previous year's winner (who was in peak form), but without having to produce his best.  His last workout since that 2013 debut was a sizzling bullet work going five furlongs in :59.3 over Keeneland's synthetic surface.  The question today is can he translate that championship form to this nine furlong distance?  I think the evidence says a big YES to that......first, he won the Fayette and the Clark at this distance, the latter a Grade 1 that earned him a 107 speed figure, which he has produced and surpassed on the turf.  Second, he should be ideally spotted in a tracking position about two lengths off the targeted front runners and have first jump on his chief rival in the next post position outside.  Third, he has the advantage of recency over that rival.  And finally, like Wise Dan, that rival is probably better going a distance different from today's race.  Would love to see him run away with this victory and come back in the Clark in six weeks when we will be at the Downs!  BIG TIME!

9-Point of Entry (7/5) - I hope he takes a lot of money because I don't think he can run with Wise Dan, at least not today, and not at this distance.  There is reason to believe he could win today, and honestly if Wise Dan were not in the race he would be a deserving favorite, but not my top choice.  While it is true that he won three consecutive Grade 1 races in New York last summer I would argue - as I did going into the Breeders' Cup - that he is highly overrated.  His rivals in those races are all horses who either have not seen the winner's circle in years and/or have never won graded stakes.  The fact that he could not run down Little Mike - who was racing beyond his comfort zone - in the Breeders' Cup Turf just confirmed my opinion of his overrated ability.  Those who like him will point out that he defeated Animal Kingdom in the Grade 1 GP Handicap at this distance last out and all Animal Kingdom did was use that to race as a stepping stone to win the $6 Million Dubai World Cup.  I would point out that nearly everyone agrees that Joel Rosario's ride that day was the worst ride he's given a stakes horse in 2013, and he made up for it in Dubai, big time.  Still, you could point out that the speed figure of 107 and the winning margin of 1 1/4 is a near mirror image of Wise Dan's 107 winning figure when he beat Animal Kingdom by 1 1/2 lengths in the BC Mile.  To which I would say it only shows they are nearly equal rivals - and that does NOT give Point of Entry an edge.  He surrenders recency, conditioning AND will have to chase down the Horse of the Year who appears primed for a huge effort today.

 


1 Black Onyx (50/1)
He's won back-to-back races, the last the Grade 3 Spiral over a synthetic track.  Outclassed here and the one hole only makes matters worse for any upset chance he might be hoping for.
2 Oxbow (30/1)
He looked like an early Derby favorite when he won the Grade 3 Lecomte at the Fair Grounds.  But he's disappointed in every start since then.
3 Revolutionary (10/1)
One of three Pletcher horses who look very dangerous in here.  The fact he's a WinStar-owned colt, ridden by Calvin Borel, drawn near the rail, and trained by Todd Pletcher all conjure up memories of Derby winner Super Saver.  He's shown himself to be game and able to work out trips in spite of trouble, which would be very helpful in a big 20-horse field like the Derby.  If anyone can work out the trip, it would be Borel.
4 Golden Soul (50/1)
Has but a single maiden win - hardly the prep you want to win the Kentucky Derby.
5 Normandy Invasion (12/1)
Interesting that Javier Castellano chose to stick with this one, who LOST to Verrazano last out instead of going with Pletcher's Revolutionary.  He was the "buzz" horse in the weeks following that fast closing finish in the Grade 1 Wood, but seems to have "fallen from favor" since then.  Would not be surprised to see him win, but I think he's a cut below the top ones in here.
6 My Lute (15/1)
I'd be happy for the connections if he won because Rosie Napravnik is riding.  But the truth of the matter he has two wins - a maiden win and a $50K Optional Claiming win.  The fact he was a neck short of Revolutionary in the Grade 2 Louisiana Derby last out says more about Revolutionary being a cut below than My Lute being up with the best of his generation.
7 Giant Finish (50/1)
His lone win was a state-bred sprint at Aqueduct.  Beaten soundly by rank outsider Black Onyx.....no.
8 Goldencents (5/1)
This colt is a legitimate win contender and proved he can sit just off the leaders which should be his position today.  He hails from the same trainer that won last year's Derby in Doug O'Neil.  I think he sits right off the longshot leader or leaders, and makes his move heading into the far turn.  Hopes will spring as he surges to the lead - but can he hold off the best three-year-olds of the east coast?
9 Overanalyze (15/1)
Looking for an upset horse who after the race everyone would shake their head and say, "I can't believe I missed him!" - well this is the guy.  He was highly rated after winning the Grade 2 Remsen at 9 furlongs to close out his juvenile season.  But in his three-year-old debut he was a flat fourth to Vyjack.  Still, you could say he needed that race.  Many did not and they paid the price when he stretched out from that mile race in the Gotham to the 9 furlong distance of the Grade 1 Arkansas Derby....and won at $9.40 (as my pick!).  So here you have the only multiple nine furlong winner in the field, who won the Grade 1 Arkansas Derby, and is trained by Todd Pletcher for Michael Repole....and he's 15/1?  Uh oh.
10 Palace Malice (20/1)
I really believe this colt will be a multiple graded stakes winner by the end of the year - just not today.  I had him in the Bluegrass and when he moved to a clear lead inside the 16th pole I thought he would be a big threat today.  But then he was nailed on the wire by a deep closer (who's in the field today), and I think he's just not ready yet for that big effort he WILL have ..... later in the year.
11 Lines of Battle (30/1)
The UAE Derby winner not only has to deal with a trip halfway around the world, but he was life-and-death to hold on that night.  I think he's simply not as good as these guys, especially on the main track.
12 Itsmyluckyday (15/1)
It would be a great day for Calder if he wins, as he's locally based.  His upset of the Gulfstream Park Derby came at the expense of MUCH lesser foes that he sees today.  His big claim to fame came in his next start when he defeated the unbeaten Juvenile champion Shanghai Bobby in the Grade 3 Holy Bull.  But besides that one, who needed the race and was exiting the Breeders' Cup off a long layoff, there was very little in the field that day as well.  In the Florida Derby he was no match for Orb and his connections quickly said that the race was NOT their goal because the Kentucky Derby was.  So, you're telling me that a Grade 1 $1 million race that is five weeks away from the Kentucky Derby is not a major goal?  Very unusual thinking.  He think he's a very good Calder horse - and that's it.  In fact if anything, his ability to give Orb a fight may be seen after the race as showing Orb is not quite as good as everyone thinks.
13 Falling Sky (50/1)
His connections have made no secret that they ARE going to the front.  I think they are the sacrificial lamb for the pressers, but because he won't have to run insane fractions to get to the lead he will probably take them to the far turn giving his connections a lot of early excitement before he fades back through the field.
14 Verrazano (4/1)
He's undefeated and answered every question posed to him on the race track.  He's trained by Todd Pletcher, ridden by Johnny Velazquez and has been the Derby favorite since before he even tried two turns and stakes company.  Velazquez has been quoted that the only colt he's been that has shown anything close to his kind of talent was the superstar Uncle Mo.  That is a high compliment.  He's shown the ability to overcome trouble and he has the perfect tracking style.  I also am very encouraged by what several handicappers/analysts had to say about the Wood Memorial.  It was his smallest winning margin, but it came after tracking slow fractions and he STILL won without having to produce his very best - AND was never threatened through the lane.  I think he gets a much sharper pace today, allowing him to track in under much more favorable conditions, and he blows by them all through the lane holding off the closers.  If he does indeed win he will be the first colt to win the Derby without racing as a two-year-old since Apollo did it in 1882!
15 Charming Kitten (20/1)
He will win graded stakes this year - on the turf.  He's the one Pletcher runner who would be a BIG surprise.
16 Orb (7/2)
Without question, he's the one to beat.  He continues to improve with each race and each training effort.  He will be mid-pack or perhaps a little farther back and should be rolling like a freight train late.  It's a little disconcerting that he is excitable, which with the huge crowd, is a concern.  And reports are he was spooked in the paddock on Thursday.  He is my sentimental pick as I would love to see Shug McGaughey get a Derby and the Janey family have been long-time racing supporters, so to get their first Derby would be a memorable sight as well.  Still, John Velazquez had his pick of Orb or Verrazano and chose the latter.  Hmmmm.
17 Will Take Charge (20/1)
After winning the Grade 2 Rebel in mid-March he's trained up to the race.  His worst effort came HERE when beaten over twenty-five lengths in the Grade 2 Kentucky Jockey Club.
18 Frac Daddy (50/1)
He won the aforementioned Grade 2 Kentucky Jockey Club and I think you can draw lines through all his winter races as nothing went right for him.  You know he loves the track and his trainer thinks he has a chance.  Not completely out of the question.
19 Java's War (15/1)
He's been known to wait in the gate and then make a HUGE late run, as he did when second to Verrazano in the Tampa Bay Derby and last out when just getting up in time to win the Blue Grass.  Was fifth behind Frac Daddy in that Jockey Club race.  Maybe picks up a minor check by finishing strongly.
20 Vyjack (15/1)
Much like Normandy Invasion he was high on everyone's list when unbeaten and heading into the Wood.  But since then he had a minor physical issue, his trainer had to deal with suspensions and getting his license to be here, and he was allowed to train here only if the barn was under 24 hour video surveillance.  Not today.
21 Fear the Kitten
On the AE list with little chance to get in and he'd be a huge surprise if he ran.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment